My ps4 d-pad right button feels weird it doesn't get that pressing feel anymore

I want to reaplace the membrane rubber in my DS4 I can only buy this parts from amazon, can anyone recommend me the best product?

I don't know if this product has the membrane or and only the plastic buttons http://ift.tt/2v41RuQ

This one has a 1 star review http://ift.tt/2tHKlcp

http://ift.tt/2v42l4k

http://ift.tt/2tHHfVC